Not every sandwich deserves glory. We travel, taste, and judge the nation’s Reubens to find the ones worthy of legend.

Serving up expert video reviews of America’s best Reuben sandwiches from Wisconsin’s very own top-rated Reuben rater - The Reubenator, Eric Burke.

The Mission

Rate My Reuben isn’t just about sandwiches.

It’s about the pursuit of the perfect Reuben.

Across diners, delis, taverns, and supper clubs, thousands of sandwiches claim greatness. Few achieve it.

We inspect them.

We rate them.

We record the verdict.


Every Reuben is judged using the RMR Reuben Index, where bread, meat, melt, and balance determine whether a sandwich rises to legend… or falls into mediocrity.